By Philip van Doorn, MarketWatch
James Shanahan of Edward Jones argues that Bank of America's shares are undervalued
J.P. Morgan Chase has a reputation as the "best in class" among the Big Four U.S. banks, but Bank of America might be a better investment if you hold the stock for the next few years, according to Edward Jones analyst James Shanahan.
In an interview Oct. 17, Shanahan pointed to Bank of America's (BAC) record $7.6 billion in share buybacks in the third quarter and massive investment in technology as catalysts for improving earnings performance and growing market share. (Buybacks lower the share count to boost earnings per share. They also reduce a bank's excess capital, which boosts returns on equity.)
Shanahan said better technology will enable the four largest U.S. banks to continue taking market share from smaller competitors.
"The biggest banks are generating so much cash flow that they have the ability to make large and substantial investments in technology and leverage those investments into larger retail deposit footprints," he said.
The Big Four are investing $10 billion to $12 billion a year in new technology, Shanahan estimated. This will "create a tech infrastructure smaller banks will not be able to compete with and will never catch up to," he said.
Shanahan expects the Big Four to leverage their growing deposit relationships "across services as they take more share over time."
A valuation play
At its current level of profitability, Bank of America's shares should be trading higher, Shanahan argues. When discussing longer-term prospects, he said: "They are kind of catching up, but within a couple of years they should reach a level of profitability similar to J.P. Morgan Chase (JPM)."
That may seem a tall order. Let's take a look at valuations for the Big Four, which also include Citigroup (C) and Wells Fargo (WFC).
Bank Ticker Closing price - Oct. 16 Tangible book value - Sept. 30 Consensus EPS estimate - next 12 months Price/ tangible book value Forward price/ earnings
Bank of America Corp. US:BAC $30.17 $19.26 $2.70 1.6 11.2
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. US:JPM $119.68 $60.48 $10.13 2.0 11.8
Citigroup Inc. US:C $69.50 $69.03 $7.53 1.0 9.2
Wells Fargo & Co. US:WFC $49.59 $33.84 $4.63 1.5 10.7
Sources: FactSet, Edward Jones (tangible book values)
So Bank of America trades higher than Citigroup (C) and Wells Fargo (WFC), but significantly lower, by both measures, than J.P. Morgan.
When Shanahan spoke of "profitability," he specifically meant return on tangible common equity (ROTCE), which he said is "the measure we pay most attention to." For banks, the denominator of that ratio is total equity, less preferred equity, goodwill and intangible assets, including loan-servicing rights.
Here are estimated 2019 returns on tangible equity for the Big Four, based on actual results for the first three quarters and Edward Jones' fourth-quarter estimates:
Bank Ticker Estimated ROTCE - 2019
Bank of America Corp. BAC 15.9%
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. JPM 19.1%
Citigroup Inc. C 12.0%
Wells Fargo & Co. WFC 13.9%
Source: Edward Jones
Bank of America's estimated return on tangible equity still trails J.P. Morgan's by a wide margin, but it is also significantly higher than the estimates for Citigroup and Wells Fargo.
Shanahan actually has "buy" ratings on Bank of America and J.P. Morgan. He believes J.P. Morgan's current premium valuation is justified because of "consistently stronger revenue and earnings growth, and industry-leading profitability," he wrote in an Oct. 15 report. But the following day, he wrote that Bank of America's price-to-tangible-book-value ratio of 1.6 was "unwarranted" because of its "strengthened financial condition and improved profitability."
Wall Street's view
Here's a summary of opinion of the Big Four among analysts polled by FactSet:
Bank Ticker share 'buy' ratings Share neutral ratings Share 'sell' ratings Closing price - Oct. 16 Consensus price target Implied 12-month upside potential
Bank of America Corp. US:BAC 54% 46% 0% $30.17 $33.07 10%
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. US:JPM 44% 56% 0% $119.68 $122.50 2%
Citigroup Inc. US:C 83% 13% 4% $69.50 $81.75 18%
Wells Fargo & Co. US:WFC 19% 70% 11% $49.59 $49.70 0%
Bank of American and Citigroup have majority "buy" ratings, with Citi the current favorite among analysts as a remedial play on its low valuation (see the first table above).
All four can also be seen as dividend plays. Here are current yields along with how much each company raised its dividend after annual capital plans were approved by the Federal Reserve earlier this year:
Bank Ticker Dividend yield Most recent increase in quarterly dividend payout
Bank of America Corp. BAC 2.39% 20.0%
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. JPM 3.01% 12.5%
Citigroup Inc. C 2.94% 13.3%
Wells Fargo & Co. WFC 4.11% 5.0%
Economic outlook -- a bright spot in third-quarter numbers
An interesting common theme Shanahan has observed this earnings season is continued strength in credit quality, particularly for U.S. consumers. Credit-card delinquencies typically increase during back-to-school shopping season, with non-performing card loans increasing through the holiday season, he said.
But despite some slowing of economic growth indicated by recent reports, third-quarter consumer-loan delinquencies "do not even reflect [normal] seasonal trends," Shanahan said.
That is a big surprise and may point to better-than-expected strength for American consumers for some time.
Don't miss:This ETF can protect you from S&P 500 volatility and enhance your long-term returns ()
Create an email alert for Philip van Doorn's Deep Dive columns here ().
-Philip van Doorn; 415-439-6400; AskNewswires@dowjones.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
October 18, 2019 13:24 ET (17:24 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.